MTG Pauper Post-Ban Analysis: What’s Winning Now?

I spent some time digging into the data to compare how decks are performing across both leagues and Challenges. Because here’s the thing: just showing up to the party doesn’t mean you’re actually winning. Some decks are everywhere, but when the stakes go up, they fall flat. Others might not be as popular, but when they show up, they mean business.

So—let’s talk about who’s really crushing it right now.

Mono-Blue Terror: The Deck to Beat

If there’s one deck that’s proving its worth on both fronts, it’s Mono-Blue Terror. This deck isn’t just showing up—it’s finishing strong. Over in the Challenges, it had 24 appearances and hit the Top 8 9 times, giving it an impressive 37.5% Top 8 rate. And in the leagues? 32 undefeated runs.

In a field that’s still adjusting to the bans, Terror feels like one of the safest and most consistent choices out there. Cheap interaction, big threats, smooth mana—it’s just doing all the right things.

Main Deck

x15

x2

x2

x4

x3

x1

x2

x4

x4

x1

x4

x4

x2

x4

x4

x4

Sideboard

x3

x2

x2

x4

x2

x2

🛒 Buy from TCGplayer🧪 Rent from Manatraders📄 Export Deck as .txt

Burn and Madness Burn: League All-Stars, Challenge Strugglers

This is where things get interesting. Mono-Red Burn and Rakdos Madness are absolutely crushing the leagues—67 and 56 5-0 runs, which is a ton. But when we look at the Challenges? The numbers drop off hard. Mono-Red Burn made 23 Challenge appearances, but only 3 Top 8s. Rakdos Madness shows the same pattern—20 entries, just 3 Top 8s.

So what’s going on here? Honestly, it feels like these decks are great for grinding through leagues where you can catch people unprepared, but once you hit a field with sideboards and tighter play, they start to lose their edge.

Main Deck

x4

x3

x3

x4

x1

x3

x1

x4

x4

x4

x4

x2

x4

x4

x3

x4

x4

x4

Sideboard

x2

x3

x2

x2

x3

x3

🛒 Buy from TCGplayer🧪 Rent from Manatraders📄 Export Deck as .txt

Grixis Affinity and Ephemerate Tron: Quiet But Deadly

On the flip side, Grixis Affinity and Ephemerate Tron aren’t showing up as much—but when they do, they’re making it count. Both decks had 14 Challenge entries, and both landed in the Top 8 5 times, right up there with Mono-Blue Terror at a 35.7% success rate.

That tells me these decks might not be the most popular choices right now, but they’re still very capable of putting up results in the hands of skilled players, especially in longer, grindier Challenge environments where sideboarding and matchup knowledge really matter.

Elves and Jund Wildfire: Big League Numbers, Missing in Action at Challenges

And then we’ve got Elves and Jund Wildfire, which have been doing really well in leagues—49 and 25 undefeated finishes—but haven’t cracked into the Challenge Top 8s yet. Either folks aren’t bringing these decks to Challenges, or they’re hitting a wall when they do.

It’ll be interesting to see if these two manage to break through as the meta keeps evolving—or if they’re just better suited for league play.

So… What Should You Play Right Now?

If you’re jamming leagues, Mono-Red Burn, Rakdos Madness, and Elves are clearly putting up results. They’re fast, they’re powerful, and they’re great at punishing slow or unprepared decks.

But if you’re looking to make a run at the next Challenge, the data’s pretty clear: Mono-Blue Terror is still the deck to beat, with Grixis Affinity and Tron looking like strong contenders right behind it. Mono-Red Burn decks are still around, but their success rate under pressure hasn’t been great.

Wrap Up

If you found this breakdown helpful, be sure to check out more over at Pauper Brews, where I’m always sharing new decks, meta updates, and spicy off-meta lists.

You can also follow us on YouTube for gameplay videos, deck techs, and more.

Thanks for reading—and good luck out there!